The 25% Difference: Why Brokers Matter When Selling Your Business

Keith McKenzie

Introduction
Selling your business is a pivotal moment, often representing the culmination of years of dedication. As you prepare—consulting your spouse or other shareholders, organizing financials, and exploring sale options—you face a critical choice: hire a broker or manage the process yourself. The decision is daunting, especially when buyers arrive with expert advisers, and broker fees seem steep. Yet, the evidence clearly says that brokers can increase your sale price by as much as 25%. This article outlines why engaging a broker is a strategic move to maximize your return.
The Professional Edge in Negotiation
Negotiation is a nuanced process where perception shapes outcomes. Hiring a broker enhances your business’s professional image, signalling credibility to buyers. A broker’s established reputation acts as a quality endorsement, reassuring buyers of your business’s stability and potential. This can shift the negotiation dynamic, reducing buyer dominance and encouraging more competitive offers. For example, a broker might highlight your business’s strengths in ways a private seller might overlook, directly impacting valuation.
Expertise That Pays Off
Business sales are complex and influenced by factors like market demand, timing, and competition. Brokers bring expertise that simplifies this process. They conduct professional valuations—often exceeding owner expectations—by analyzing financials, market trends, and comparable sales. This ensures your asking price reflects true value. Additionally, brokers are adept negotiators, building rapport with buyers to maintain trust while strategically managing offers. Their experience prevents missteps that could derail negotiations, securing you a better deal.
Access to Exclusive Resources
Brokers offer resources private sellers rarely access. Through extensive networks—such as proprietary databases or industry connections—they connect you with qualified buyers, increasing visibility and sparking bidding wars. This heightened interest strengthens your negotiating power. Brokers also possess deep market knowledge, levelling the playing field against seasoned buyers. Moreover, their due diligence—reviewing your business’s financials, operations, and legal standing—streamlines information sharing with buyers, making the process efficient and transparent.
A Worthwhile Investment
Broker fees may seem like a significant expense, but the return justifies the cost. Research, including a study by Agrawal et al. (2023), shows that sellers using brokers achieve net profit increases of 6% to 25%. Top-tier brokers often deliver these results without higher fees, as their expertise drives superior outcomes. For instance, their ability to identify optimal buyers and negotiate effectively can far outweigh their commission, making them a smart investment for maximizing proceeds.
Conclusion
Hiring a broker offers unmatched advantages: professional credibility, expert negotiation, access to buyers, and a proven profit boost. While concerns about cost or self-sufficiency are valid, the data is clear—brokers bridge gaps and elevate your sale’s success. If you’re ready to sell, contact our team today. Our brokerage services can guide you through every step, ensuring you achieve the highest possible return.
Citation
Agrawal, A., Cooper, T., Lian, Q., & Wang, Q. (2023). Does Hiring M&A Advisers Matter for Private Sellers? Quarterly Journal of Finance, Forthcoming. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2400531.